Fifth Ward residents: EPA is holding back contamination report
Local officials say a preliminary draft of the air, soil, and water test results is ready but has not been made public since October.
By Samuel Ellis ·

Residents in Houston’s Fifth Ward are demanding the release of a preliminary environmental report that they say could determine the safety of their homes. The community, located near a former railroad site, has waited three years for the federal government to finalize testing on local air, soil, and water. According to U.S. Rep. Christian Menefee, a draft of the results has existed since last October but remains unavailable to the public.
The dispute centers on a 125-acre tract of land previously operated by Southern Pacific Railroad, which later merged with Union Pacific. In 2019, the state of Texas designated the Greater Fifth Ward as a cancer cluster. Union Pacific officials stated they submitted a report to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in October 2025 and provided additional information in April 2026. Menefee argues that a preliminary draft of these findings is currently sitting with the agency.
The history of the site involves the use of creosote, a chemical applied to treat wood that is now linked to higher cancer risks. EPA officials have indicated that chemicals from the site contaminated local groundwater over the years. The upcoming report is intended to document current conditions and outline potential remediation steps. Until that data is released, families in the neighborhood remain uncertain about the safety of their immediate surroundings.
The urgency of the situation was highlighted at a press conference held on Monday. Rep. Menefee told the crowd that community members were learning of new deaths while standing at the podium. He described a mother trying to determine if her backyard was safe for her children. Joetta Stevenson, chair of the EPA Community Advisory Group, stated that the agency has been sitting on the information despite their efforts to move the process forward.
The impact of the delay is felt most acutely by those with existing health conditions. Annetta Dwellingham Humphrey, whose daughter Aaniyah is currently undergoing chemotherapy for Hodgkin Lymphoma, expressed the family's fear that the cancer is related to local contamination. Aaniyah was born and raised in the Fifth Ward. Humphrey described the wait for answers as overwhelming and heartbreaking.
The EPA has not yet responded to requests for a specific timeline on when the contamination results will be published. Stevenson emphasized that the people with cancer and those dying in the community deserve the data immediately. The report will serve as the primary document for deciding what, if anything, can be done to improve the current environmental conditions in the area.






