Netanyahu retains war powers despite caretaker status
Legal analysis confirms the outgoing leader can authorize military action against Iran, even as US officials push for a diplomatic deal.
By Samuel Ellis ·

President Isaac Herzog has formally tasked Gadi Eisenkot with forming Israel's next government. This move places Eisenkot in charge of coalition talks based on recommendations from 67 Knesset members, a number that exceeds the 46 who recommended Benjamin Netanyahu. Despite this shift in the political balance, Netanyahu remains prime minister. He retains full executive authority, including command over the defense establishment and the power to direct policy toward Iran.
The situation creates a legal and political tension. The Knesset elections have concluded, but the outgoing government still holds power. Under Section 30 of the Basic Law: The Government, an outgoing government continues to perform its duties until a new one is formed. Section 40 of the same law states that Israel may not initiate a war without a government decision. However, the law allows the prime minister to delegate this authority to the security cabinet for reasons of national security or secrecy. There is no legal distinction between a regular government and a caretaker government regarding these powers.
The question of authority has become urgent due to the diverging strategies of Israel and the United States. US President Donald Trump recently stated in an interview with CBS's 60 Minutes that he sees no need to resume strikes against Iran at this stage. During a meeting at the White House with Qatari Prime Minister Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani, Trump reiterated that the US military is prepared to act if circumstances change, but he hopes for an agreement. Secretary of State Marco Rubio supports this view, arguing that economic sanctions and a naval blockade are effectively damaging the Iranian regime.
In contrast, Netanyahu advocates for a tougher approach. In a speech to the Knesset on Wednesday, he argued that overthrowing the ayatollahs' regime is the only way to permanently eliminate the Iranian threat. He warned that the international community might accept a resumption of Iran's nuclear program. While US Vice President JD Vance has been engaged in daily indirect contacts with Iranian mediators, Netanyahu maintains that diplomatic efforts are insufficient. Reports from the Financial Times indicate that Arab leaders are concerned Netanyahu is pressuring Trump to resume the military campaign.
The security cabinet has not met since October 5, before the Knesset elections. It is scheduled to convene on Sunday, November 15, for the first time in over a month. During this gap, the defense establishment received instructions to increase readiness for a possible strike on Iran. This preparation raises questions about which forums are conducting security discussions while the government operates in a caretaker capacity. The last meeting of the cabinet predates the current political transition, meaning recent strategic assessments have been made without a formal cabinet vote.
Historical precedents suggest that caretaker governments can and do launch military operations. In December 2008, Ehud Olmert, serving as a caretaker prime minister, oversaw Operation Cast Lead in Gaza. In May 2021, Netanyahu himself launched Operation Guardian of the Walls while serving in a caretaker role. That campaign lasted 11 days and was triggered by rocket fire. In August 2022, Yair Lapid and Benny Gantz led Operation Breaking Dawn, which began with an Israeli-initiated strike. In that instance, the security cabinet did not convene because the Attorney General accepted that the operation was unlikely to lead to a full-scale war.
Legal experts note that Supreme Court rulings require outgoing governments to exercise restraint and act proportionately. The obligation to be cautious is less restrictive when facing an immediate security threat. However, the legal difficulty increases if the government considers an operation that could be postponed without compromising operational objectives. Netanyahu cannot independently authorize every war decision; if the action falls under Section 40(a), it requires a decision from the full government or the security cabinet acting under delegated authority.
Eisenkot sent a letter to Netanyahu on Wednesday night demanding restraint in security decisions during the caretaker period. He warned against deploying forces in the absence of a direct and immediate threat that cannot be postponed. The letter highlights the friction between the incoming and outgoing leaders as they prepare for the next phase of the conflict with Iran.






