Mace introduces bill to limit Congress to natural-born citizens
The resolution would extend presidential eligibility rules to legislators and judges, a change requiring a two-thirds vote in both chambers of Congress.
By Isaac Nair ·

Rep. Nancy Mace, R-S.C., introduced a joint resolution on May 20, 2026, that would amend the U.S. Constitution to restrict federal office to natural-born citizens. The proposal, designated H.J. Res. 188, targets members of the House and Senate, federal judges, and Senate-confirmed officials. The measure currently sits with the House Judiciary Committee. It has not yet been voted on by the full House.
The bill would close a gap in current constitutional rules. Today, the Constitution requires the president and vice president to be natural-born citizens. It allows naturalized citizens to serve in Congress and on the federal bench, provided they meet other residency and age requirements. Mace argues that officials holding federal power should meet the same origin requirement as the executive branch. Her resolution would apply this standard to all federal elected and appointed roles.
Mace defended the measure by emphasizing loyalty to the United States. She stated that those who write laws or confirm judges should have a single allegiance. "If you hold power in the American government, you should be a natural born American citizen," she said. She added that this requirement is not complicated. The people representing America should not be loyal to Somalia or any other country.
The congresswoman named three specific Democratic lawmakers as examples of the need for the change. She identified Rep. Ilhan Omar of Minnesota, Rep. Shri Thanedar of Michigan, and Rep. Pramila Jayapal of Washington. Mace said these representatives have made clear their loyalty is not here. She claimed the amendment would end the practice of foreign-born members holding seats while showing divided loyalties. In a later television interview, Mace said she would support making the rule retroactive. She said she would be fine applying the restriction to current members of Congress.
Critics argue the proposal discriminates against naturalized Americans. Rep. Jayapal called the legislation racist. She said it denies the history of a country shaped by immigrants. Jayapal noted that many voters elected naturalized citizens to office. She urged her colleagues, including Republican naturalized citizens, to condemn the move. Jayapal said the effort is insulting to the constituents who voted for these representatives.
Rep. Omar offered a brief response when asked about the resolution. She said, "Good luck to her." Rep. Thanedar responded with a social media post. She suggested lawmakers should instead restrict members who make their staff vote on personal popularity contests. The post was a sarcastic critique of the new proposal. It highlighted the absurdity of adding new rules to congressional conduct.
The path to enacting the amendment is steep. It requires a two-thirds majority vote in both the House and Senate. It then needs ratification by three-fourths of the state legislatures. The proposal does not apply to state or local elected officials. It is limited to federal offices. If ratified, it would change eligibility rules for the highest levels of government. It would affect Americans who completed the naturalization process before winning elections.
The legal definition of a natural-born citizen is specific. It does not require that a person be physically born on American soil. The current rule for the presidency already uses this definition. Mace's bill extends that same legal standard to the legislative and judicial branches. The debate continues as lawmakers consider the implications for representation.






