Justice Civil Division: Top Lawyer Resigns Amid Midterm Shifts
Brett Shumate departs immediately, leaving the division without leadership as it faces hundreds of active lawsuits and internal friction.
By Fatou Girard ·

Brett Shumate, the assistant attorney general for the Civil Division, resigned from the Justice Department on Monday. His departure is effective immediately. He leaves a division that is currently defending the federal government in a high volume of lawsuits. These legal battles have intensified since President Trump took office.
Shumate's exit adds to a string of high-profile departures that have occurred since Democrats won control of both the House and Senate in the recent midterm elections. Last week, the assistant attorneys general for the Justice Department's Tax and other key divisions also left their posts. Those offices now lack Senate-confirmed leadership.
In a statement on X, Attorney General Todd Blanche praised Shumate's record. Blanche noted that Shumate pursued affirmative litigation to challenge sanctuary policies. He also credited Shumate with securing victories in lawsuits against local policies that he said endangered federal law enforcement.
Shumate is a former partner at the law firm Jones Day. He previously served in the Civil Division during the first Trump term. Attorneys in the division viewed him as a reasonable and decent leader. This perception stood in contrast to the chaotic environment within the department. The agency has had to adopt novel legal positions to defend the government against hundreds of active cases.
Under Shumate's leadership, the department defended the firing of many career civil servants. Many of those workers received only a letter citing Article II of the Constitution as the reason for their dismissal. The division also defended aggressive mass deportation policies. It has further defended renovation projects personally directed by the president, including the tear-down of the White House East Wing to build a ballroom, along with overhauls of the Kennedy Center and the East Potomac Golf Course.
The division also faces a wave of lawsuits from detained immigrants. A Justice Department-run immigration court recently ruled that the government can detain many immigrants indefinitely while their removal proceedings are pending. Lawyers in the division were surprised by the abruptness of Shumate's resignation. Sources told CBS News that his departure was unexpected.
His timing follows a major shift in the White House hierarchy. Stephen Miller was named White House chief of staff late last week, replacing Susie Wiles. One source familiar with the matter told CBS News that Miller has been critical of Shumate in the past. Miller reportedly believed Shumate was not aggressive enough in his legal strategies. This internal friction was a factor in Shumate's decision to step down.
Separate personnel changes are also underway. T. Elliot Gaiser, the assistant attorney general for the Office of Legal Counsel, is being considered for a judgeship in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas. A Senate aide confirmed that the Justice Department submitted his nomination paperwork. Gaiser authored the classified legal justification for military boat strikes against suspected drug traffickers. He has no direct ties to Texas other than a one-year clerkship in the Fifth Circuit.






